Street-level light rail cheaper than monorail or elevated LRT

29
1470

The infrastructure cost for street-level light rail vehicles (or new generation trams) is much lower than the monorail and elevated light rail transit options put forward in the revised transport masterplan for Penang.

From what I gather, these are the infrastructure costs for the various urban rail options:

Street-level light rail: RM40m/km
Monorail: RM170m/km
Elevated LRT: RM220m/km

So the question is, why is the project delivery partner going for monorail and elevated LRT when the original transport masterplan consultant (Halcrow) had recommended trams and bus rapid transit? Why the change?
In fact, the original tram routes proposed by Halcrow have now been inexplicably reduced to a miserable 2km stretch (with just six stops) in inner city George Town that appears targeted at tourists.

Bear in mind that that new generation street-level light rail vehicles can take as many passengers as an elevated LRT system at less that one fifth the infrastructure cost. And although these light rail vehicles run at street level, they can go up on ramps at difficult or congested stretches (see video above).

For the 17.5km Komtar-Airport elevated LRT route, the cost works out to RM220m/km x 17.5km = RM3.85bn. Add to that ancilliary infrastructure costs, and you arrive at the RM4.5bn figure mentioned in press reports last year.

But if we had street-level light rail vehicles or a new generation tram system, we would reap massive savings in infrastructure costs which could then be used for an expanded and more flexible rail and bus rapid transit network (including on the mainland) instead of a rigid and inflexible elevated LRT and monorail system focused mainly on the island.

READ MORE:  Abolishing tolls: Short-term gain, long-term pain

So why are they going for the more expensive options?

Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.

29
Join the conversation

avatar
2000
15 Comment threads
14 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
23 Comment authors
UtopiaLight Rail FailsLapalaEricglissantia Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Utopia
Guest
Utopia

Support re-route PG LRT away from 3 schools in Sg Nibong Penang that have over 4k of students to ensure a tranquil learning environment in the schools:

https://www.facebook.com/3MinutesOfTranquility/info?tab=page_info

http://www.chinapress.com.my/20160421/支持輕快鐵改道避開學校-公眾可授權3校提訴求/

Light Rail Fails
Guest

Are you sure? #lightrailfails

Eric
Guest
Eric

I believe Anil were not a penang resident. A land system on Penang island? This is totally … hell. Penang already very congested in the traffic and there are not enough space for road. Imagine that you want to connect Komtar with Gurney, unless you want demolish certain building, your rail planner either go through penang road or burma road. These 2 road are about 3-4 single direction lane but even so it alway having traffic jam. If you going to build a land system, it would take up at least 2 Lane for the rail and what about when… Read more »

glissantia
Guest
glissantia

I suppose BRT sounded good at the time of elections. Now, we have to think of “political” funding, generous foreign donors and offshore accounts. BRT is not promising in that sense. At most, you lay out an extra lane along the route, and each bus – even the best – may cost max. RM 250,000.

Tua Pai Kiah
Guest
Tua Pai Kiah

Anil
This Sat 16 April 2016, 3.30pm-5.30pm Dialogue Session on Penang Transport Plan (Laluan LRT di Bayan Baru) at Level 4 Sunshine Square Auditorium organised by MP Sim Tze Tzin.
See you there.

roy
Guest
roy

A good place and time for Anil and his ardent readers to meet.

Jetty
Guest
Jetty

http://www.penang-traveltips.com/bayan-lepas-lrt.htm

No LRT to Queensbay Mall or to Bayan Baru Market/Sunshine Square, so people will not find LRT convenient!

For sure Kwang Hwa Primary School supporters near Sg Nibong have strongly object to the set up of a station. Reason noise pollution and safety of pillars only 6 metres away.

Jetty
Guest
Jetty

NO to LRT Penang from Kwang Has Primary School board.

http://www.kwongwah.com.my/?p=126171

Alex Yap Shaw Liang
Guest
Alex Yap Shaw Liang

One consideration would be space for surface rail. And if ee consider the properties that may need to be demolished to build a surface rail it may actually be quite high. If we build it on the road it may make our roads even more congested.

bumi non malay
Guest

Good thing don’t come cheap, Cheap things don’t come good….. BUT Under UMNO-BN Administration Malaysia they are all EXPENSIVE AND POOR QUALITY and continue the IDEOLOGY of 1% Malay Holading the Equity & Wealth of 99% of Malays….. And you Expect things to improve when every corruption income is mover overseas with Bank Negara Approval …Lets face it Non-UMNO state are performing better….if like PAS wants to bed with UMNO & have hudud…then that state also like UMNO states….ABU ..UBAH Pecat PBB-Adenan-Taib from Sarawak!!…how about LRT or MRT in Sabah-Sarawak too??

gk ong
Guest
gk ong

Like that who will want Gerakan to come back?

kaycee
Guest
kaycee

Besides taking up more land LRT or Mono Rail compete with traffic in congested Penang. Underground MRT although expensive but worth it over the long run. If Federal government not prepared to fund it then LGE should fight for private funding.

Oon Chooi Huat
Guest
Oon Chooi Huat

Anil, space constraint esp in Penang!

David Loman
Guest
David Loman

Why not go Lawatan Sambil Belajar at Singapore (don’t worry about losing Bin Chui) to learn from their MRT and LRT experience? Singapore has limited land space but still able to have a good MRT/LRT network.

http://www.thesundaily.my/node/359833

Ravi123
Guest
Ravi123

Anil can employ Tunglang to visit SingLand and return with a report for anilnetto.comon best transport option for Penang; and hopefully he returns with a lion roar and lose his phobia for the cats.

zoro
Guest
zoro

no need to employ him. he will do all means. to discredit his cm. fast the cm goes away better his heath. now no time for kopi or or sg pinang or and belum valley.

Cheong Kian Kok
Guest
Cheong Kian Kok

But land expensive

Gwynn Jenkins
Guest
Gwynn Jenkins

when fees work on a %, the cheaper option is not so desirable

Rscrugby
Guest
Rscrugby

Because kapcais in Asia will block their way. Everybody in cars, trucks and buses have to make way for kapcais. The trams will too. In Europe and Melbourne ok.

Richard Loh
Guest

SPACE, do we have enough space on street level? More trees have to be removed, land acquisition, more relocation etc?

rajraman666
Guest
rajraman666

Anil
You can tell millions times but the more expensive is their choice.More expensive more ….you can decipher my meaning.
Above ground or elevated one need land for structure and under the structure it’s waste of space but some people’s don’t agree.

rajraman. I closed my cased without further defence.

zoro
Guest
zoro

milions times. of course deity gets millions in discount but what about billions times when 1 mbd is involved. of course we get cheap items in pasar malam. any further discount if sourced from pasar malam trader? otherwise missed opportunity. why buy one that depends on driver. china is ahead in drones which is automatic wo dtiver. elevated trains do not required and driver on trains. further if one tram is delayed, when it arrives 3 or 3 trams of the same route arrives at the same time. the first tram will be packed like sardines and the second and… Read more »