The Penang Forum steering committtee released the following ‘executive summary’ to the media during its meeting with the chief minister of Penang:
To address public concerns over hill degradation in Penang, the Penang Forum took the initiative in September 2015 to co-organise a public forum on hill development with the MBPP and relevant Penang state authorities.
But the council and the state decided not to participate in the effort and missed the opportunity to engage with the public.
In organising the public forum, the Penang Forum is non-partisan and has not been influenced by any other body or organisation.
The Penang Forum has not been misinformed. Its information and data came from two sources:
- answers provided by the State Exco to the State Assembly sitting in November 2015 on the number of legal projects and illegal clearings on sensitive hill land between 2008 and 2015; and
- photographs provided by members of public, resident associations, Google Earth satellite imagery and drone shots.
The scarring on Bukit Relau has grown into an unmitigated disaster. Despite a stop work order and a fine against those responsible, major earthworks, including the building of road infrastructure, have taken place.
While it is technically possible to build safely on hill slopes many stringent conditions must first be in place and complied with. The present approach to environmental and engineering impact assessment done in isolation for individual hill development projects should be reviewed.
The Penang Forum calls on the Penang state government to comply with its own stated policies of prohibiting development on hill land above 76m (250 feet) and/or with a gradient greater than 25 degrees.
Special projects should be limited only to those of public interest.
We recommend that the authorities implement a holistic planning and monitoring system that takes account of cumulative impacts for the whole hill area under development.
We call for violators to be prosecuted to the full extent of the law, including jail sentences and to be blacklisted for future projects.
We call upon the authorities to require all offenders to restore the damaged hills to their original condition
Penang Forum steering committee
11 January 2016