Reformasi (bukan Reklamasi-lah)! The ‘compensation’ spin

54
354

Not many years ago, when people protested against mega projects in Penang including property development on sensitive hill-slopes, the state government would warn us that if the projects were cancelled, the state would have to incur “hundreds of millions in compensation” payouts to developers.

This time, as the cries of #PenangTolakTambak ring louder, the state government seems to be falling over itself to “selesai” the problem by talking of dishing out compensation, including bigger boats for the fishermen.

It is as if all the massive problems of the disastrous RM46bn PTMP and the 4,500-acre southern reclamation plan to create three artifiical islands could be resolved simply through compensation payouts to fishermen – never mind the enormous social and environmental costs to the people of Penang.

Even Anwar Ibrahim appears to be singing a modified version of the same compensation tune – some other vague talk of improvements thrown in – despite being surrounded by #PenangTolakTambak banners during his recent visit to Penang. :

Obviously, he had not received the memo.

If he had, he would have known the fishermen’s three requests to the National Physical Planning Council at the end of their memo, which they hand-delivered during their recent protest in Parliament:

  • Cancel the reclamation in the south.
  • Undertake a comprehensive review of the entire “PTMP” by independent transport experts and planning professionals.
  • Place a moratorium on sand-mining activities in the waters off the coast of Perak.

Check out how strongly they conveyed their unmistakable message on their way to Parliament:

If the government insists on bulldozing the reclamation through – and the fishermen then find themselves with their backs against the wall – then and only then would the issue of compensation for the fishermen and so-called “transformation” of fisheries arise.

READ MORE:  PDC has 4,500 acres of land in Batu Kawan - so why create three islands?

But those in power have ingored the fishermen’s three requests – even though they have received the memo. (Funny that – because they claimed that they have held over 4,000 consultations sessions with the fishermen – although the Penang Fishermen’s Association says they have met the state only once. Somebody is having a problem with maths.)

Instead state government leaders have latched on to incessant talk about negotiating compensation (many Penang people are so tired of that word) and fulfilling the growing and “tedious” list of “conditions” and “nasihat”.

One way of looking at this litany of conditions is that the various departments and ministries are trying to cover their backs by putting in all these conditions in case things go wrong.

But even though the DoE has attached 72 conditions to its EIA approval for the reclamation and even though the federal government has not yet approved the project, the Penang state government seems to be going ahead with its “phase 2”, whatever that means.

Nurul Izzah might be out of government, but she is more clued in with the people’s concerns, having also visited the fishermen recently.

She might not be aware of the intricacies of the damaging transport infrastructure components and details of the enviromentally unfriendly “PTMP” (she has called for alternative solutions to finance the PTMP rather than raising funds through reclamation). Notably, though, she has called for a more sustainable (“lebih lestari”) plan.

It is apparent that Nurul Izzah is against the massive reclamation, raising some uncomfortable questions about the whole reclamation business in Parliament. Check her out in action below:

READ MORE:  Forum: Reclamation - a ticking time bomb?

Good for her! Showing some real leadership qualities there – unlike many of her fellow MPs who are as silent as churchmice on this issue or kowtowing to their party bosses.

Meanwhile, concerned Penangites are venting their frustration on social messaging platforms by coining their own acronyms to rival the official so-called Penang Transport Master Plan (PTMP), which is drastically different from the original transport plan by Halcrow consultants:

Penang Offset Master Plan = POMP, reflecting the pompous talk of compensation to bulldoze the reclamation through. POMP is supposed to fulfil some of the concerns by the Developers over Environment – or rather, Department of Environment – over the reclamation.

Penang Infrastructure Master Plan = PIMP. Never mind.

Then, there’s this:

It is sad that it has come to this. Like many Malaysians, many Penangites voted for Reformasi! – but perhaps their calls have been misunderstood. For, in Penang, all they seem to be getting is non-stop Reklamasi.

Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.

54
Join the conversation

avatar
2000
12 Comment threads
42 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
Ken SongBTS MutiaraIT.ScheissLim Goh PohDon Anamalai Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Lim Goh Poh
Guest
Lim Goh Poh

Ringgit is weak. Nations with stronger cirrencies exploit Penang development. They easily can afford many which now appear expensive to locals. Penang islanders better less kbkb and learn to deepen pocket. If no shall become servants to rich powerful outsiders, becominh housekeepers, gardeners, babysitters, security guards, shopping malls attendants etc. No joking here.

IT.Scheiss
Guest
IT.Scheiss

Looks like that’s what Malaysia is heading towards. Who knows, 20 years from now, Malaysians could be working as exploited foreign workers in neighbouring countries.

Shriek
Guest

We will be servants or continued to hunter of fish if we don’t progress. Tulang’s children have to go to kl or singnland just like you. Why you are from Thai border. Why go to klang valley?

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

It is time for tunglang to explain to Anil’s readers, using the Michael Porter’s “The Competitive Advantage of Nations”, how Malaysia is positioned against low cost neighbours (Vietnam, Cambodia, Indonesia) and highly advanced neighbor Singapore.

https://hbr.org/1990/03/the-competitive-advantage-of-nations

Ken Song
Guest
Ken Song

Tun Lang is very smart with MBA from Belum University should be able to expound on the Harvard masterpiece to enlighten us on the competitive advantage of Penang!

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

I am not a since-day-one-boss unlike somebody with a golden spoon & no need to work for others since day one.
With all his decades of spoon fed, where can any sweating-working class match his song-song working life?
Even his stringing a sentence like “smart with MBA from Belum University” can also sell to any Tom, Dick & Hairy of Love Lane!

How about ‘Penang with a Song-Song Golden Spoon’ pitching to PDC?
Btw, that 1996 red cover book was too full of golden spoons to sell again to new century PDC!

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

Some Malay­sians are facing difficulty in repaying their loans, especially those earning less than RM5,000 per month and residing the urban areas, says Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir.

He said the household debt in the country now stands at 82.1% of the country’s gross domestic product (GDP).

This, he said, is higher compared to other countries with greater income capita such as Italy, which is at 40.3% of its GDP, Japan (58.1%), and the United States (76.3%).

https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2019/07/24/cd-some-living-beyond-their-means/#uGtGct6UIOrBxpIS.99

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

Residential property needs ‘realistic’ evaluation https://www.thestar.com.my/business/business-news/2019/07/20/residential-property-needs-realistic-evaluation/ Pg DAPCAT should look at what’s coming – continuing ominous property hanging that may stymie economic development via financial implications (bad debts, unserviceable home loans, lower spending) if state gomen continue to be myopic & arrogant at property play (just to finance a monstrous PTMP that doesn’t create & spread wealth for all except for a few greedy ones). Other neighbouring countries like Thailand, Vietnam & even Red Dot have emphasised creating, building & nurturing local talents to prepare for the competitive future of GotTalents,CanGoFar, not focusing solely on property industry as a driving… Read more »

Shriek
Guest

Tulang. What about overhang of graduates? Soooo many unis and soooo many graduates? You may have talents but no real jobs. Can you bring out the coffin money and invest it to give employment to youth? Now vring out real mobey and wheb you not around, we can burn back to you. 4wds and condos

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

Many overhung graduates get low pay and unable to repay PTPTN loan.

What is the ROI of PTPTN?
Burden to taxpayers?

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

RU talking thro’ your …? (Anil may censor this, up to him)
That’s the quality of trolling on the verge of suicidal desperation!

Gabby Benson
Guest
Gabby Benson

3 reclaimed islands are exclusively created for prestige reason. Meant to pull in wealth outside the realms of Penangites to create new caste system, so that bin chui chasers being lured to reach out for new value$ in life to sustain ego if not maximise it during lifetime.

Don Anamalai
Guest
Don Anamalai

Reformasi is already history as Civil War is now happening in PKR.

MAHATHIR means the A after M could be Azmin, followed by H for Hishamudin or Hadi?

A lot will happen between now and next GE!

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

The curse of the same-sex video is repeating, starting in 1997, another in 2008 & now this one.
All following the man who was supposed to succeed PM Mahathir.
Anyone out there who is well versed with the 4 Pillars of Destiny reading to give one reading for AI?

IT.Scheiss
Guest
IT.Scheiss

Yes. With this infighting intensifying within PKR, It does not look like the leading politicians at the top have much time for any other more pressing issues affecting the economy, cost of living and so forth which impact us ordinary Malaysians.

Shriek
Guest

Good, you can have ummo and najib back. At last you dream comes through. When are you going to celebrate and sing celebration?

BTS Mutiara
Guest
BTS Mutiara

World recession inevitably gonna happen accelerated by Trump aggression towards China and Iran. Cyber trade and ideology warfare going on too long. Time to send human home to reflect on many things going awry!
Human mind development is more critical for long term survival if we cannot sustain with physical development clashing with nature.
AI and IR4.0, shrieking frightening but no hehe laughing subjects.
What’s your plan if the world economy is booming for dooming????

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

Meanwhile down south the people there eagerly awaiting the $100 billion smart island city:
https://youtu.be/QFG-PIJ0GUE

Luaskan Kuasamu!

Wei
Guest
Wei

even more destructive, more grandiose, more opulent yet not a squeak from our high moral tree hugger….their hatred is fixated on Penang government…their ego prevent them from alternative thinking…hehe

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

After-the-fact-of-sea-reclamation test case @ Tanjung Tokong (TT):
What has happened to the fishermen livelihood? More catch or dwindling catch? More damaged nets?
How are those fishermen who were compensated doing now? Better or worse?
Are TT fishermen fishing in deep seas?

DOE should reexamine the undeniable fallout of sea reclamation at TT before approving any new reclamation in the state so as to avoid a repeat of mistakes that cannot be undone @ TT.

Shriek
Guest

Tulang, everyday you sapu sure habits. every day is out going. So it will dry up. You kbkb will orso dry up. Where do you get fish replacement.

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

This is for the benefit of doubt (of proof) of Ken Song: Extract: Funny that – because they claimed that they have held over 4,000 consultations sessions with the fishermen – although the Penang Fishermen’s Association says they have met the state only once. In the legal scrutiny, isn’t it absolute lying by the state apparatus to claim otherwise so as to hoodwink the public for an ulterior motive to achieve an insidious objective? What iota of hope (Sikit Harapan) is there for Penang & the whole of Malaysia when the very political entity by association with Pakatan Harapan (association… Read more »

Shriek
Guest

Tulang, why surprise over 4000 consultations? Every day and every hours or second they go lim kopi and one ton mee. Very casual more effecrive. Can get better result. With lim kopi and one ton mee you still kbkb

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

Going by this latest report from Msiakini, we can expect more reclamation in Johor for exclusive housing?
https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/268842

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

Island of Sorrow!

Premier League outfit Penang’s joy turned to sorrow when they were barred from competing in the Super League, due to uppaid wages to Lobo (not the one with the dog named Boo).

https://www.thestar.com.my/sport/football/2019/07/22/island-of-sorrow/#vmKLI5L9itZK2gKF.99

BTS Mutiara
Guest
BTS Mutiara

Penangites don’t support state team but idolize English football clubs. Locals like Anil never go city stadium or Batu Kawan to lend support so how to elevate the status???

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

Anil, my objectives to comment here have accomplished & here’s one of them – to irritate the KneeJerks to reply in sensible discourse on issues at heart so we can share some feedbacks & solutions. Instead I get leeching-on nonsensicals as well as trollings in bad tastes! And I don’t even pay a cent to these 2 shrieking & he-he trolls to make me noticed if not famous! C’mon, try harder shrieking & he-he.
Btw, Hungry Ghost Month is nearing, so my advice here is get some spiritual protection before shrieking like Pontianak / Kuntilanak or he-he-he like mischievous ghosts!

Wei
Guest
Wei

cry baby cry father cry mother going berserk when countered by fact, reason, and right thinking….LOL

Shriek
Guest

What feedback do you give? You still drive 4wds, look for chip one ton mee and lim kopi. Shift from heritage and stay in condo. What positive feed back?

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

Here we see the 2 guilty-conscious shrieking & he-he trolls replying.
No need to name names before in my above comment – just leave it to the knee-jerking motor respond!
This is how to deal with these kind of trolls if you have one – irritate.

Wei
Guest
Wei

hehe…anwar’s reformasi being hijacked by arrogant tree hugger…now need to consult with tree hugger what is and what is not reformasi beside consult them what is and what is not sustainability, and beside consult them what transport plan work or does not work….might as well tree hugger take over CM position…LOL

Anfield
Guest
Anfield

How about reclaim the eastern side of the island instead, to join up with Prai, then no need the bridges in the future?