Auditors qualify opinion on accounts of firm tasked with Penang tunnel feasibility study


Auditors have had to qualify their opinion on the accounts of Astral Supreme Bhd, whose wholly owned subsidiary, Astral Supreme Construction Sdn Bhd, had entered into a joint-venture agreement with Penang tunnel consortium member Zenith PMC Sdn Bhd to carry out feasibility studies and detailed design work for certain roadworks and the Penang tunnel.

The firm also has had to explain a 154 per cent deviation between unaudited fourth quarter results for 2013 and its audited financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2013.

The auditors also said they “wish to highlight the unaudited unusual large payments amounting to RM12.84 million alleged to be made by the former Managing Director during the financial year”.

In an investigative review, Special Auditors, among other things, probed the veracity of certain payments to third parties as deposits. They found that “a payment of RM0.84 million by a subsidiary and treated as deposit purportedly to undertake feasibility study on a project could not be reasonably determined due to lack of documentation. Subsequent to the financial year end, a sum of RM0.60 million was refunded by the third parties and the balance will be impaired notwithstanding ongoing efforts are being made to recover the balance”.

Which feasibility study is this and who are the “third parties”?

In August 2013, Astral Supreme Bhd entered into a joint venture agreement with Zenith PMC Sdn Bhd to carry out the feasibilty study and detailed design work on certain roadwork and the Penang tunnel for an aggregate contract sum of RM275m. Astral Supreme stands to receive a minimum of RM15m and keep 25 per cent of profits with the balance 75 per cent going to Zenith.

It is unusual for auditors to qualify their opinion on the financial statements of a listed firm.

Astral Supreme Bhd’s announcement of the qualification in its auditors’ report is as follows:

In accordance with Paragraph 9.19 (37) of the Main Market Listing Requirements of Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad, the Board of Directors wishes to inform that the Auditors’ Report on the Audited Financial Statements of the Company for the financial year ended 31 December 2013 contains a qualified opinion by the External Auditors, Messrs Morison Anuarul Azizan Chew. Details of the qualification are as follows:

“Emphasis of Matter

We draw your attention to Note 42 to the financial statements. The Group had reversed revenue amounting to approximately RM4.88 million during the current financial year due to certain unusual sales.

We also wish to highlight the unaudited unusual large payments amounting to RM12.84 million alleged to be made by the former Managing Director during the financial year.

Basis of Qualified Opinion

As disclosed in Note 5 and 9 to the financial statements, the Group has entered into a sales contract in the previous financial year amounting to RM41.08 million. The contract was subsequently terminated by the customer during the current financial year. Pursuant to the sales contract, property, plant and equipment and inventory were acquired with carrying amount of RM2.73 million and RM2.41 million respectively as at 31 December 2013. In view of the uncertainty over the continued usage of the property, plant and equipment and the subsequent sales of the inventories, we were unable to obtain sufficient evidence to ascertain the recoverability of the property, plant and machinery and inventory as at 31 December 2013.

Qualified Opinion

In our opinion, except for the effects of the matters referred to in the Basis of Qualified Opinion paragraph, the financial statements give a true and fair view of the financial position of the Group and of the Company as of 31 December 2013 and of its financial performance and cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with Malaysian Financial Reporting Standards, International Financial Reporting Standards and the requirements of the Companies Act, 1965 in Malaysia.”

The firm also had to explain the deviation in its unaudited fourth quarter results and its audited financial statements as follows:


The Board of Directors of Astral Supreme Berhad (‘ASupreme’ or ‘the Company’) wishes to announce that the Company has on 28 February 2014, submitted its unaudited 4th quarter results to Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad (‘Bursa Securities’).


In compliance with Paragraph 9.19(35) of the Main Market Listing Requirements of Bursa Securities, the Board wishes to inform that there is a deviation of about 154% between the Group’s loss after tax and minority interest as stated in the unaudited 4th quarter results ended 31 December 2013 (‘QR for 4Q 2013’) announced on 28 February 2014 and Audited Financial Statements for the financial year ended 31 December 2013 (‘AFS 2013’). The deviation is reconciled and explained as below:–

AFS 2013 (“RM’000”) QR 4Q 2013 announced on 28 February 2014 (“RM’000”) Variance (“RM’000”)
(Loss)/Profit after tax and minority interest for the year (10,081) (25,584) (15,503)

The major causes of the variances between the announced unaudited results and the audited results

The major causes of the variances between the announced unaudited results and the audited results are due to the adjustments made on the exceptional items of possible irregularities pursuant to the Investigative Audit conducted by PKF Advisory Sdn Bhd, adjustments and reclassification of cost of sales and others items by External Auditor as follows:-



Adjustment to reversal of sales


Impairment of amount owing by associate company


Impairment of deposits


Reversal of impairment in trade receivables


Impaired of trade receivables


Impairment in advance to creditors


Selling marketing






Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.
Notify of

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ong Eu Soon

12 March 2014 PETALING JAYA – Astral Supreme Bhd, which saw a shift in its boardroom recently with the entry of Datuk Eddie Chai Woon Chet, has secured letters of award (LOAs) worth a total of RM105 million for housing projects in Malacca. In a filing with Bursa Malaysia yesterday, the group said its wholly-owned subsidiary Astral Supreme Construction Sdn Bhd received the LOAs from Gemawan Bina Sdn Bhd (RM57 million) and Permata Rebana Sdn Bhd (RM48 million). Astral Supreme Construction will undertake the sub-contract for design, build and associated works for the housing development projects and is expected to… Read more »

Stylo Logan

I urge the readers of this blog to be careful in their comments.
Najib is now watching us…

Don Anamalai

Yes, look at what has happened to Malaysiakini.
Do not get Anil into trouble.

Stylo Logan

You got my point.
But we must all support Malaysiakini!


This case is somewhat smelly so is the Kidex or the Jais Hindu wedding intrusion. It is very fishy and Pakatan govt in Penang under DAP LGE and in Selangor undert PKR Khalid are keeping quiet, in denial or not wanting to comprehend the real situation. And where are all the DAP & PKR supporters and why are they keeping quiet.

Aisay man

I would to say it’s a load of … with that silly association in between the rats !


You mean the Cat is playing blind & seek with the rats in a modelled tunnel?
Anything goes in the dark (tunnel) below the sea level.

Ong Eu Soon

Ong Eu Soon made a wild allegation on corruption by proxy and caused some trouble unforeseen by anyone.


Speaking of corruption, Hishamudin finally admitted that the armed forces and Esscom is infected by such disease. Perhaps he tried to tell us that it was a legacy from his predecessor Zahid Hamidi? But Zahid can also say PDRM is no better when inherited from Hishamudin?

Don Anamalai

Transparency International Malaysia (TI-M) has urged MACC to act on Defence Minister Hishammuddin’s claim that corruption is among the reasons for the repeated border security breach in Sabah.

I simply cannot understand why MACC is not proactive in this matter.