Open mic for Penang: Residents ‘rant and rave’ about state’s growing pains

89
223

Gabungan Bertindak Malaysia (GBM) and Aliran held a Rant & Rave 2.0 session in Penang on Saturday.

This was a platform designed to let participants speak openly, without fear or favour, on the performance of the “unity government”.

True to its concept, the session had no keynote speakers. The floor was given entirely to participants, encouraging authentic, ground-level feedback and diverse perspectives.

Held at Coex @ Kilang Besi, the event drew active engagement from participants who valued the openness and inclusivity of the platform.

Traffic congestion, overdevelopment and housing affordability were the issues that dominated the discussion. These are longstanding concerns among people in Penang.

Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

89 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Smiley Sim
Smiley Sim
14 Apr 2026 9.42am

Why use such negative terms ‘rant and rave’, no different from local slang Kpkb. Need to be more positive to be constructive!

Twinkle
Twinkle
15 Apr 2026 6.56am
Reply to  Smiley Sim

To “rant and rave” means to express intense anger or frustration by talking loudly, wildly, and uncontrollably, often at great length. It describes a passionate, often irrational, outburst or furious complaining about a topic. While “rave” can sometimes mean to praise enthusiastically, in this combined idiom it indicates negative, wild speech.

Solomon
Solomon
18 Apr 2026 11.34am
Reply to  Smiley Sim

Negative connotations indeed. Sounds like noise making session for the frustrated folks that have difficulty keeping up with time.

Molly
Molly
18 Apr 2026 4.58pm
Reply to  Anil Netto

Next time can call it ‘lively and positive’ to give good vibes!

Twinkle
Twinkle
2 May 2026 11.30am
Reply to  Molly

Meanwhile it is Rain n Rave in Bukit Bintang… Can bring in more tourist dollars? Can try at Gurney Bay too?

Screenshot_2026-05-02-09-47-27-874_com.facebook.katana-edit
Sorie Mah
Sorie Mah
21 Apr 2026 1.04pm
Reply to  Anil Netto

Care to elaborate those lively discussion? Any video recording uploaded to youtube?

Looney Tunes
Looney Tunes
25 Apr 2026 10.58am
Reply to  Sorie Mah

Nothing to show?
Let readers judge if the session is constructive.

Royce Choo
Royce Choo
20 Apr 2026 2.47pm
Reply to  Solomon

Yes, be positive for positive change.

Already too much noise everywhere.

Rakyat 8
8 May 2026 4.52pm

” PM Anwar proposes Asean food security standby arrangement during crises ”

https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2026/05/08/pm-anwar-proposes-asean-food-security-standby-arrangement-during-crises

========

When the Russia-Ukraine war began in February 2022, politicians, economists and business leaders were loudly talking about food self-sufficiency and national security. Then the Madani government took over in November 2022.

Fast forward to 2026, and they are still repeating the same talking points amid the ongoing US-Iran conflict. The real question is: between then and now, what meaningful structural changes were actually made? My guess: very little.

Rakyat 8
7 May 2026 11.29am

” PJ fatal crash involving elderly river sparks racist chants after police wording confusion ”

https://focusmalaysia.my/cops-miswording-of-skidded-vs-speeding-senior-citizen-driver-in-pj-fatal-crash-triggers-racist-chant/

========

Malaysia’s roads have become like war zones. One may enter to travel, but may not come out alive.

Every day, reckless driving and dangerous riding have become a common sight, as many motorists show little concern for their own safety or the lives of others.

The daily death toll on our roads now feels worse than that of a war zone, affecting people regardless of ethnicity.

Rakyat 8
3 May 2026 10.54am

” Nearly 40 hours on, no news of M’sians abducted on Global Sumud Flotilla vessels ”

https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/774109

========

We, the Rakyat, have our own problems here and are struggling with the rising cost of living in Malaysia. It has not been resolved since the Madani government took over. The cost of living continues to increase and is getting worse day by day.

As for yourselves, since you made the bed, you have to lie in it. As the Malay proverb says, “Sendiri buat, sendiri tanggung.”

Rakyat 8
18 May 2026 11.12pm
Reply to  Rakyat 8

https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/05/18/anwar-slams-israel-demands-release-of-16-malaysians

========

It’s like a badly written script repeated over and over again — by a PM, no less.

Twinkle
Twinkle
1 May 2026 10.14am

More schools, companies and community groups in Singapore are setting up micro-gardens to grow their own greens, with some urban farming providers reporting up to a 30 per cent increase in demand. The rising interest comes as Singapore steps up efforts to strengthen food resilience.

glissantia
glissantia
10 May 2026 12.24pm
Reply to  Twinkle

Even if the plants grown are not food, every square metre of metal, glass, masornry or road shielded from sunlight means the “heat island” effect becomes more tolerable for the non-rich, and nights cooler and more restful for all. Though Singapore is closer to the equator, its peak daily temperature is consistently below ours.

But we have a long way to go. A few days ago, a highway authority said building highways is good for the economy.

Rakyat 8
30 Apr 2026 5.31pm

Half a month later today on 30th of April 2026 the following statement was made –

” PBAPP seeks federal intervention to avert water crisis in Penang, Kedah ”

https://www.thevibes.com/articles/news/122437/pbapp-seeks-federal-intervention-to-avert-water-crisis-in-penang-kedah

” PENANG Penang Water Supply Corporation Sdn Bhd (PBAPP) has sought immediate intervention from the Federal Government to avert a potential water crisis in Penang and Kedah following declining levels of Sungai Muda and increasingly worrying capacity at key dams.”

>>> Note the words ” immediate intervention “. What happened to ” piped water is stable ” mentioned just 14 days ago?

Nezha Mutiara
Nezha Mutiara
19 Apr 2026 12.44pm

Gentrification of Penang, slowly becoming a reality….

https://youtu.be/3cgqK7G23BA?si=vXCba28_J2cfobN2

Rakyat 8
20 Apr 2026 10.30am
Reply to  Nezha Mutiara

The title may overstate the case. 

What is shown appears to be the commercial transformation of selected heritage districts, particularly those tied to Chinese urban history, rather than the gentrification of Penang in its broader historical and multi-ethnic context. 

Penang’s story has never belonged to one quarter alone.

Twinkle
Twinkle
28 Apr 2026 5.39pm
Reply to  Rakyat 8

GEORGE TOWN: The Penang government said all negotiation efforts with Waterfall Cafe had failed, with the operator rejecting multiple relocation proposals despite repeated notices to vacate the premises.

This came as enforcement action today saw the demolition of the 103-year-old structure at Taman Botani here.

Rakyat 8
29 Apr 2026 7.08pm
Reply to  Twinkle

If one does not own the land and redevelopment is moving ahead, the smartest move would have been to negotiate the best exit package, then focus on expanding the business, not fight a battle that was unlikely to be won.

They may have made a costly strategic mistake if they rejected a workable relocation despite lacking ownership of the land.

Twinkle
Twinkle
11 May 2026 5.07pm
Reply to  Rakyat 8

Residents and community groups in Gelugor, Penang, are actively opposing a proposed high-density mixed development project on Lot 642, a site often used as an informal green space. Locals are urging the government to scrap the, “mega project” and protect the area from becoming a “concrete jungle”.

Rakyat 8
18 Apr 2026 1.24am

” AI just a progress in technology, not aimed at replacing workforce, says Penang CM ”

https://www.thevibes.com/articles/culture/115563/ai-just-a-progress-in-technology-not-aimed-at-replacing-workforce-says-penang-cm

While ,

” AI is changing careers: What SPM graduates must do next ”

https://www.thestar.com.my/starpicks/2026/04/17/ai-is-changing-careers-what-spm-graduates-must-do-next

========

The two statements reveal a clear difference. Penang CM says AI is only a progress in technology and not aimed at replacing workers, which seems reassuring.

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 8.51pm

” We do not believe in political divorce and remarrying’ – PM Anwar”

https://www.thevibes.com/articles/news/123849/we-do-not-believe-in-political-divorce-and-remarrying-pm-anwar

========

Then, all the political rhetoric against UMNO should stop in the current Johor state election.

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 8.30pm

” Penang government comes under fire from Protect Karpal Singh Drive members” https://www.thevibes.com/articles/lifestyles/123846/penang-government-comes-under-fire-from-protect-karpal-singh-drive-members ======== The state government is not so accountable and transparent after all, are they? After being the state government for over 20 years, they now seem to be engaging in a lot of political gymnastics. This is more than enough proof of why we should think carefully before continuing to vote for them. They no longer seem to practice the C.A.T. principles they once championed. In the meantime, what happened to MP Rayer? Was he not the one who said that the Chief Minister would not proceed… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 8.29pm

One reason this may be happening is that any political party which believes it enjoys guaranteed support from its voter base can gradually become less responsive to criticism.

Accountability is strongest when voters are willing to question and scrutinize every party equally, regardless of political loyalty.

Given what we are seeing today, should Penangites continue placing their trust in DAP?

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 2.53pm

” Johor MB’s exclusionary rhetoric betrays the people, exposes UMNO’s political hypocrisy ”

https://www.thevibes.com/articles/opinion/123818/johor-mbs-exclusionary-rhetoric-betrays-the-people-of-johor-and-exposes-umnos-political-yypocrisy

========

The problem with this article is that it repeatedly conflates refusing to work with DAP with refusing to represent all Johoreans.

The writer is interpreting a political disagreement with DAP as a rejection of non-Malays or a rejection of Bangsa Johor, when those are not necessarily the same thing.

A political party can choose not to cooperate with another political party while still governing for all citizens regardless of race, religion or background.

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 2.53pm

Bangsa Johor has always been about the people of Johor as a whole, not about any particular political party.

Political cooperation is a choice. Governing fairly is a responsibility. The two should not be confused.

Having said that, if Johor UMNO’s position is unacceptable to PH, then what does PH intend to do about it at the federal level?

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 1.23pm

” Chinese apathy may see PAS take Putrajaya, says ex-MCA chief ”

https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/06/10/chinese-apathy-may-see-pas-take-putrajaya-says-ex-mca-chief

========

Yet again, PAS is being made the political bogeyman.

Is this all these politicians know how to say?

After years of repeating the same warning, perhaps it is time to tell voters why they should support you instead of constantly telling them who they should fear.

If your case is strong, it should be able to stand on its own merits.

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 1.10pm

” Penang financially strong, don’t compare with Johor, says Chow ” https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/06/08/penang-financially-strong-dont-compare-with-johor-says-chow ======== Penang was already in a strong financial position under the previous administration. As the next Chief Minister, you inherited a state with substantial reserves. Yet within just over four years, the state’s reserve fund reportedly fell from RM2.1 billion to only a small fraction of its previous level under the current adminstration. The question is: why? The state embarked on programmes that required millions of ringgit in funding, many of which people would argue were unnecessary or simply duplicated efforts already being carried out by the federal… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 1.09pm

At the same time, annual operational expenditure grew significantly while development spending lagged behind, steadily eroding reserves that had been built up over many years.

Having depleted much of the state’s reserves, the government then began increasing revenue through higher charges and fees linked to state-controlled assets and services.

Why has this become the preferred approach?

Has the state exhausted all other avenues of generating revenue? Or does it simply not know how to do so?

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 1.08pm

Utility charges, parking fees, quit rent and assessment rates are not optional expenses. The Rakyat cannot simply switch to another provider. We are effectively pushed into a corner with little choice but to pay. It is easy to claim financial strength when revenue continues to rise. The real test is whether that financial strength is achieved without placing a heavier burden on ordinary Penangites. Financial strength should not be measured solely by the amount of money collected by the state. It should also be measured by whether the people can afford the cost of living or does not the DAP… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
10 Jun 2026 11.39am

” Ramasamy: Blame PAS if PH emerges triumphant in GE16, PMX returns to office for a 2nd term in office ” https://focusmalaysia.my/ramasamy-blame-pas-if-ph-emerges-triumphant-in-ge16-pmx-returns-to-office-for-a-2nd-term-in-office/ ======== Ramasamy says Malaysians will lose a strong opposition if PAS and Bersatu part ways. But has the Opposition really provided strong and effective checks and balances since 2023? Criticising the government is one thing. Offering credible alternatives, influencing policy, and holding the government meaningfully accountable is another. The Opposition may have the numbers, but numbers alone do not automatically translate into effectiveness. Perhaps before worrying about a split, we should first ask whether the Opposition has been… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
9 Jun 2026 2.27pm

” Anwar warns against AI power concentration ” https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/06/09/anwar-warns-against-ai-power-concentration ======== We have been discussing digitalization, technology and AI for years. None of this came as a surprise. The direction of travel has been clear for a long time. The signs of digital transformation and AI were already there years ago. Technology has continuously evolved, from industrialization to computerization, digitalization and now AI. The pattern was visible for anyone willing to see it. Those who recognized the trend invested, built capabilities, developed talent and took risks. Today, many of them are leading the field. It is therefore not surprising that they… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
9 Jun 2026 2.26pm

Malaysia has talented people, capable engineers, researchers, entrepreneurs and technology professionals. What we need are the right policies, consistent support, investment and a business environment that encourages innovation. AI is a field that requires vision, commitment and significant resources. Rather than spending our time talking about why others are ahead or focusing solely on the risks, we should be focusing on how Malaysia can develop its own capabilities, support local talent and attract strategic partnerships and investments. Every major technological revolution has brought challenges and concerns. That is nothing new. However, history generally rewards those who adapt, innovate and build.… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
9 Jun 2026 2.25pm

The future will belong to those who build, innovate and adapt.

We should spend less time discussing why others succeeded and more time discussing what Malaysia needs to do to succeed itself.

The question we should be asking today is this: What is Malaysia doing to ensure that we are not merely consumers of future technologies, but contributors and builders as well?

A Rakyat 8
9 Jun 2026 11.34am

”  PAS calls it quits with Bersatu ”  https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2026/06/09/pas-calls-it-quits-with-bersatu ======== PAS calling it quits with Bersatu may be a good move if PAS wants to move forward politically. Today, PAS has 43 MPs while Bersatu has only 19 MPs. Yet whenever major political issues are discussed, disagreements between the two parties seem to keep surfacing. Perhaps the alliance has reached its limits. The bigger question is this: What comes next? PAS can win many Malay-majority seats, but Malaysia’s political reality is that no single party can govern the country on its own.  If PAS wants to be part of the federal government… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
9 Jun 2026 11.33am

Bersatu carries its own political baggage. Gerakan and MIPP have yet to show that they can attract enough support to make a meaningful difference.  At the same time, PAS continues to face difficulties gaining the confidence of many non-Malay voters. Unless PAS is prepared to convince non-Malays through both words and actions that it can govern for all Malaysians, that trust gap will remain. In the end, PAS’s biggest challenge may not be Bersatu. Its biggest challenge is finding coalition partners and expanding its support beyond its traditional base without losing its own identity. That is the political dilemma PAS… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
31 May 2026 8.52pm

” Will Permatang Pauh emerge as a potential battleground for Anwar’s electoral future? ” https://www.thevibes.com/articles/news/123485/will-permatang-pauh-emerge-as-a-potential-battleground-for-anwars-electoral-future ======== “We remain focused on helping Anwar win in whatever seat he chooses to defend. The odds are tough as in every election, especially since Anwar’s clarion calls for reforms send shivers to his rivals, who are afraid of persecution if he wins,” . >>> PKR insiders and members seem to have learned very little since then. We, the Rakyat, have seen the Prime Minister accumulate more DNAAs than actual reforms or prosecutions. The irony is that the same ruling leaders, including the PM himself, keep… Read more »

A Rakyat 8
31 May 2026 8.51pm

For instance, even a relatively straightforward promise such as limiting the Prime Minister’s tenure to 10 years or two terms has yet to materialize despite the unity government’s parliamentary majority.

To many Rakyat, it increasingly appears to be a promise made to win support rather than a reform intended to be delivered.

The same can be said about the separation of the Attorney General’s and Public Prosecutor’s offices, an issue that has been under discussion since 2018.

After so many years, the excuses are wearing thin. The Rakyat can see the gap between promises and actual delivery.