Crystal-ball gazing: ‘ISA’ finally repealed in 2025


Half a dozen years ago, to mark Singapore’s 40th Independence Day in 2005, a Singapore website  invited me to write an imaginary news-report about Malaysia exactly 20 years into the future i.e. 9 August 2025.

In keeping with the spirit of freedom and liberation, I chose the topic of the ISA and allowed my mind to wander and wonder what it would be like when the announcement finally came that this obnoxious law would be repealed. I imagined euphoric scenes of joyous celebration across the nation.

Back in 2005, the opposition parties were hardly united and I figured any repeal would only happen in 2025. But four years later, in 2009, 50000 people marched through the streets of KL under the banner of the Abolish ISA Movement (GMI), demanding an end to this much-reviled law. Yesterday, with a general election looming, Najib of all people pre-empted my 2025 forecast by announcing the ISA would be repealed.

But there are, of course, two provisos to his announcement. We don’t know when the statute will actually be repealed in Parliament. And we can bet that we have not seen the last of preventive detention or detention without trial laws. No wonder, unlike the jubilant scenes described in my article below, the public reaction to Najib’s announcement has been flat. Kamunting is still open for business; no ISA or EO detainees have been released. And Aung San Suu Kyi has not sent any congratulatory message following the PM’s announcement. Instead, the PSM 30 are facing trial on 10-14 October and the ISA will probably be “rebranded” and reincarnated into two new laws for anti-terrorism and “public order”. (Who defines “terrorism” and “public order”, anyway)? Najib is smart but ordinary people have wisened up and they can see right through his “reform” package. An aunt of mine, not ordinarily interested in politics, remarked, “Ai-yah, you believe him ah? All this just for elections-lah.”

So, if we are talking about preventive detention laws, my 2025 prediction may still be valid! After all, no one is celebrating just yet – and rightly so. We can’t celebrate until the last of the preventive detention laws are finally repealed and our judiciary reformed so that it becomes truly independent. I just hope we don’t have to wait for 2025 for that!

This is my crystal-ball gazing piece written in 2005:

Kuala Lumpur, 9 August 2025 – In a stunning development, Malaysia has announced that it is repealing the Internal Security Act 65 years after its enactment.

The move to abolish the law, which allows indefinite detention without trial, came after years of campaigning by a coalition of civil society groups known as the Abolish ISA Movement.

The decision to repeal the ISA was also one of the central planks of the reformist election manifesto of Malaysia’s new prime minister, who won a general election earlier this year after promising to usher in a new era of genuine bottom-up democracy.

A couple of hours’ drive north of Kuala Lumpur, in the industrial town of Kamunting, there were jubilant scenes marking the end of an era as the last group of security detainees at the infamous detention centre here walked out. “It’s good to be free,” said Abdul Manaf Ismail, who was mobbed by reporters as he emerged through the gates tearfully. “I never expected this – I was prepared for the worst.”

He was greeted by his wife, Suraya, and their two children, Zulkifi and Shirleen, who had travelled all the way from Malacca.

The move to get rid of this archaic law is expected to ripple through ASEAN. Campaigners expect Singapore and Brunei to announce a repeal of almost identical laws in their respective countries while other ASEAN nations are also likely to abolish similar preventive detention laws.

Malaysian grassroots groups and activists in neighbouring ASEAN countries had strongly lobbied the Malaysian government to abolish the law, a relic of British colonial rule from mid-20th century Malaya. The law was initial used against communists and left-wing groups from the 1960s but was then expanded to zero in on an assortment of groups and individuals who were allegedly involved in actions “prejudicial to national security”.

After the Sept 11, 2001 attacks in the United States, the ISA and preventive detention laws received a new lease of life as hundreds of suspected militants, allegedly linked to Al Qaeda, were rounded up across the world. But preventive detention laws fell into disrepute in the years that followed after horrific accounts of torture and abuse of prisoners emerged from Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, Guantanamo Bay in Cuba, and Bagram air base in Afghanistan.

Burma’s former prime minister Aung San Suu Kyi, who has become an inspirational figure for the pro-democracy movement in ASEAN, sent a congratulatory message to the Malaysian government. “This is a great day for the Malaysian people and the people of ASEAN,” she said. “I understand full well what it means to be detained without trial and to be denied natural justice, so I want to salute the Malaysian government for doing away with the ISA.”

Suu Kyi, who recently celebrated her 80th birthday, spent more than a dozen years in detention after her pro-democracy movement was brutally suppressed by Burma’s military regime. Upon her release from house arrest 15 years ago, she contested in the country’s first free elections in years, going on to become prime minister of Burma briefly, before stepping down to make way for younger leaders in her party.

At the secretariat of the Abolish ISA Movement in Kuala Lumpur, Kamal Yusuf was euphoric. “We have waited a long time for this day,” he said, as colleagues sang and danced in their office. He pointed out that repeal of the ISA was a vindication of the principle of natural justice that a person should be presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

“I wish to acknowledge the immense contribution of all those who took part in the struggle,” he added. “More importantly, this victory for freedom- and justice-loving people would not have been possible if not for the persistence and tenacity of all those have campaigned against the ISA down the years.”

In a related development, the ASEAN secretariat said plans for an ASEAN Court of Human Rights were well on course. The Court would hear appeals on human rights cases in the region and would itself allow further appeal to the newly set up Asian Human Rights Court.

The move follows the setting up of national human rights commissions in all ten ASEAN member nations. In recent years, the last three of the ASEAN nations without such bodies – Singapore, Brunei and Burma – announced they had agreed to set up commissions in their respective countries.

Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.
Notify of

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gopal Raj Kumar
Gopal Raj Kumar
18 Sep 2011 1.26pm

Nothing can prevent a government’s right to detain a person on the basis of suspicion of the commission of an offense and keep them in custody indefinately. it happens in the US and in Britain, in Germany and in France, in China, India and in Japan.

Repealing the ISA is cosmetic.

17 Sep 2011 8.02pm

Anil, this’s my dedication to your wonderful vision shared by many Asean nationalities:
The Impossible Dream-Man of La Mancha

Remember to say: “We have waited a long, long time for this day,”

17 Sep 2011 9.51am

“To dream the impossible dream. To reach the unreachable sky”
These UMNO goons who have tasted power and wealth will not give
up their position so easily. ISA is their license to rule…what will happen, just call me by another name….what is the difference between water and H2O?

Gerakan K
Gerakan K
17 Sep 2011 8.35am

Eeeeeeee, anil. Tak tau malulah. Mau ikut cara pembangkang nak dapat kredit kerana pemansuhan ISA dan EO ???

ISA dan EO dimansuhkan oleh sebab dasar pembaharuan yang diperkenalkan oleh 1Malaysia PM Najib dan bukan desakan/bunyi bising yang dibuat oleh pembangkang.

Oleh itu jangan bikin malu dengan membuat kenyataan bahawa permansuhan ISA dan EO merupakan usaha pembangkang. Sebaliknya, kita perlu berterima kasih kepada 1Malaysia PM Najib, kerana dasar pembaharuan beliau, ISA dan EO dimansuhkan.

Kredit sepenuhnya kepada 1Malaysia PM Najib. Saya percaya rakyat akan menyokong kerajaan BN sepenuhnya dalam pilihanraya yang akan datang.

17 Sep 2011 9.08pm
Reply to  Gerakan K

Ai yer, Gelak K, apa apa yang you kata itu semua buat saya banyak geli dan mau muntah la…

Only the bodoh people will vote for BN because of this repeal. Sudah diperbodohkan for the past half a century, tak cukup lagi ke?

Anyone will know it is a political ploy !!!

Gerakan K
Gerakan K
18 Sep 2011 8.00am
Reply to  kee

Pada pendapat saya, segala tindakan kerajaan merupakan tindakan politik kerana melalui politik, kerajaan dibentuk dan tindakan kerajaan seterusnya memberi perkhidmatan/pembangunan kepada rakyat dan negara.

ISA dan EO jika tidak dimansuhkan pun BN dapat mengekalkan kemenangan pada pilihanraya akan datang. 1Malaysia PM Najib mempunyai matlamat yang mulia dan sedia mendengar kehendak rakyat serta melakukan apajua demi kebaikan rakyat dan negara.

Apa sumbangan roket kepada negara ???