Why the GST is not necessary


At a recent talk on the GST, I asked those present what they thought “GST” stood for. Most of those present responded, “Goods and Services Tax”.

Then, I showed them a cartoon by Zunar which described GST as “Golfing, Shopping, Travelling”! They got the joke and laughed knowingly.

But humour aside, the concern over the impending Goods and Services Tax was evident on the faces of those who attended the talk at the Church of the Risen Christ in Air Itam, Penang.

The first thing to note is that the GST is a regressive tax. It is a significant move away from the somewhat progressive tax system that we used to have.

The more we earn, the more we take from others, the living and the dead - Graphic: Chiok Phaik Fern
“The more we earn, the more we take from others, the living and the dead. To lead a blameless life, we ought to give back to society.” – Graphic: Chiok Phaik Fern

Why is it regressive? It shifts the burden of tax away from the rich to everyone, including the vast majority who are struggling to make ends meet. And instead of a consumption tax imposed on certain items, this time only few items are exempted.

Full article on Aliran website

Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.
Notify of

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gregory Bramadesa
Gregory Bramadesa
24 Apr 2016 12.16am


Check out d rates of other governments … UK is the worse…

22 Mar 2015 11.52am

What people need to watch out for is actually how much the GST collection will exceed the expected projected amount – THAT actually represents the inefficiency of the govt. The more successful GST is, the more it shows how badly BN govt really has been in performance in collecting taxes.

22 Mar 2015 10.20am

My neighbor said GST to him was Government Sangat Teruk upon realising that his purchasing power would be eroded 6% along with GST and shrinking Ringgit.

22 Mar 2015 10.08pm

We must understand that Zonar is a Pakatoon sycophant. Anything that is a first will cause some anxiousness but In 6-9 months time everything will be back to normal. GST has been implemented in more than 170 countries out of 200 countries in the world and it did wonder to their economy. In SE Asian the Philippine, Indonesia, Singapore, Vietnam & Thailand also implement GST and is moving forward. Myanmar may not have GST but its a … not among the in the world but also among countries of SE Asia. Lets move forward. GST is the way .

Ed G
Ed G
24 Mar 2015 11.17am
Reply to  Yang

“Anything that is a first will cause some anxiousness but In 6-9 months time everything will be back to normal”.

I wonder if this phrase is more appropriately applied to our mega-scandals like BFM, NFC, PKFZ, 1MDB, Scorpene, MH370 etc. Or the perpetual cycle of public uproar, promises of investigations and actions by our leaders followed by predictable foot-dragging and finally stealthy closing of the cases for the above scandals plus many others like the irregularities cited annually in the auditor general reports,

24 Mar 2015 1.48pm
Reply to  Yang

Kenapa tak ikut Singapura, mula GST dengan 3%?
6% terlampau tinggi untuk golongan miskin!

GST = Government Siap Tumbang?

27 Mar 2015 2.37pm
Reply to  ad

Government Suka Tipu!

malcom x
malcom x
17 Mar 2018 7.44am
Reply to  Yang

its already 6-9 months im writing this on 2018/3/17.. you must be a “cog” for BN i guess