38% of households struggling to make ends meet
According to the latest household income survey, the following are the percentages of families in the various monthly household income brackets.
| Household monthly | Percentage | |
| income range | of families | |
| < RM 1000 | 8.6 | |
| RM 1001 – 2000 | 29.4 | |
| RM 2001 – 3000 | 19.8 | |
| RM 3001 – 4000 | 12.9 | |
| RM 4001 – 5000 | 8.6 | |
| RM 5001 – 10,000 | 15.8 | |
| > RM 10,000 | 4.9 | |
| 100.0 |
Source: Figures presented by Senator Amirsham A Aziz, Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department, in response to a query in Parliament by Dr Jeyakumar Devaraj, MP for Sungai Siput
If you assume that families earning below RM2,000/month are having a really tough time making ends meet, then 38 per cent of all families are in that predicament.
If we take RM3,000 as the threshold for those who are barely coping, then that makes it more well over half the number of Malaysian families who are going through lean times.
This is the real problem in Malaysia today - not the inter-ethnic income disparities.
And the government still doesn’t want to heed the MTUC’s call for a minimum wage of RM900/month and a cost of living adjustment of RM300?
After nearly 40 years of fairly rapid FDI-driven economic growth and over 20 years of neo-liberal policies, to what extent has the quality of life for families really improved - even with more than one person in the household working or the breadwinner taking up an extra job? Instead, we have a vast gulf between the rich and the poor, as a sense of disillusionment sets in. This partly explains why the BN did badly at the polls.
Now the question is what kind of solutions can the PR offer if they come to power to tackle such structural disparities - apart from the urban-rural poverty gap? Will eradication of corruption alone solve the problem - or is the problem a more deep-rooted structural one?
We need to be looking at development policies that truly benefit the people - people-centred development - instead of being so obsessed with the ethnic breakdown of equity ownership and policies that only benefit Big Business.
Email this to a friend
Printable version
- TNB CEO’s monthly pay = 5 yrs’ pay for poor households
- How about helping the poor at home first, Najib?
- Terengganu poverty reduction: Did Pas do better?
- The real issues at stake in Sarawak
- Selangor’s public declaration of assets, minus the assets
Loading ...
This is how sad we are……….
http://siakhenn.tripod.com/capita.html
A more precise list of per capita income is this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capita
Our per capita income is so low causing people to struggle to make ends meet and yet, we can send Angkasawan to space.
And clowns tell us petrol in Singapore cost more than in Malaysia!
But the price of petrol is nothing to a Singaporean.
This letter by a reader of Malaysiakini summarises how sad the earnings of Malaysians are and attribute the low income earning capacity to Corruption
http://www.malaysiakini.com/letters/85764
I’d be interested in the PR’s proposal too. In their fierce criticism, where lies their plans and priority? I’d say let them have publicly telecast debates on real issues like these. Although knowing certain politicians, it’s more likely to be turned into one freak circus show.
Can you survive with RM3000 permonth in Malaysia?
http://www.thekualalumpurtraveler.com/can-you-survive-with-rm3000-in-malaysia/
Dear Anil
They are waiting for 2/3 of the population to be affected b4 taking action, as they are fixated on this 2/3 thing! lol
I’m not a great believer in conspiracy theories, but lately I’m beginning to think seriously about these rumours making the rounds that our Rulers for 50 years have seen the writing on the wall and have embarked on scorched-earth policies so that Pakatan will inherit a desert to work on!
Any subscribers to this hypothesis?
I do not think giving cost of living adjustment is a wise move. Cost of doing business will increase. This will only give excuse for traders to further raise the prices of goods and services. That will result in spiralling inflation. We have seen this happening every time the salaries of government servants are raised.
A better solution is to adjust the personal income tax structure in this coming Budget. Allow a higher tax relief income from the present RM8000 to maybe RM12000. Also, revise down the personal income tax by 2 to 3% for the lower income brackets.
This way is more subtle. I hope our government listen to this piece of advice.
It makes little difference to government budget. No doubt, my suggestion will reduce budget revenue. But, this is better than paying cost of living adjustment that will increase budget expenditure.
Lower tax rate will also reduce tax evasion and avoidance problems. With more people reporting their taxable income, the government will benefit in the longer term.
The critical level of income for this current situation is below or equal to RM3,000 based on dependents, loan repayments etc. Actually 50% of Malaysians are now living under stress to make their ends meet.
Dear All
This is why we need social democracy and well-implemented public policies in Malaysia!
1. Keep public sector health care heavily subsidised. End all the rent-seeking schemes that drive up costs for the Ministry of Health.
Rationale: Heavy medical bills can force people into bankruptcy. People from the lower classes are dependent on good physical health to earn a living.
2. Abolish all fees in Malaysian public schools and provide full scholarships to smart students from poor families to attend public university. Raise fees for postgraduate students (unless they are from poor families).
3. Build a better public transport infrastructure. Tax petrol-guzzling private cars heavily to discourage their use. Make our cities and towns more pedestrian and bike-friendly.
4. Introduce a minimum wage
5. Make the ACA independent and put more effort into fighting corruption
6. Set up an unemplyment insurance scheme
7. Introduce a monthly child welfare allowance for all families
with children under the age of 5
8. Learn from the progressive countries of Northern Europe that have strong social democratic political parties such as Finland and Sweden
cjcm,
Yes you can, but sadly not in KL.
greetings,
can we survive with Rm 3,000 a month in Malaysia?. It depends. If you live in Kampung, you already have a humble kampung house, do not use car but motorcycle instead, grow your own padi field, catch own fish, than I thing rm 3,000 is more than enough. But if we live in cities with house rent, car repayment, petrol, utilities, maid to take care children, we are in deficit mode every month.
Yes, Donplaypuks. They’re running this country into the ground and they’re 2/3 done.
…. ” Learn from the progressive countries of Northern Europe that have strong social democratic political parties such as Finland and Sweden”
Hi, Phua Kai Lit
You have stated some very important and practical policies of many successful nations . But, will this racist xenophobic BN regime implement these principles without bias??
Aussie PM congratulates Badawi and the rakyat for the way in which the we handled the democratic transformation in this country. So why the reluctance to meet up with Anwar, mate?
While the sufferings of the Rakyats are clearly spelled out in those statistics, the Government is still targetting grandiose Infrastructure projects that would eventually benefit a close circle of CRONY COMPANYS.
The ordinary Rakyats, if given just a 10% chunk of the cost of the grandiose infrastructure cost to re-invent themself with either 1. Small Scale agriculture production in terms of Cash-Crops, or
2. Small business with low capital out lay,
3. Small capital for service industry,
would have BETTER ideas than the POLLUTED Brains of the Cabinet, in utilising monetary allocations.
Whatever Master Plans that the Government have put in place, or the So-called 9th Malaysia Plan, or Mid-term Reviews, ….who eventually benefit from them???
Sad to say, all those grandiose plans have not benefitted the Majority. And those coming plans are merely self-serving, politically -centered purpose.
Please look at the performance of fiscal spending by our neighbour Thailand. The ordinary Thais are politically smart to change the Government whenever they under performed.
The Government Administrative Buildings countrywide in Thailand are just a simple structure.
But we have PUTRAJAYA, and many more. Are we proud of it, to see grand structure of the twin Tower, whereas many country folks are struggling to feed themself.
I believe the title should be 57.8% of households struggling to make ends meet.
Mind you that you are talking about household income here and not personal income which makes a big difference. The average household size in Malaysia, if I am not mistaken is 4.5. If the data was broken down by race (not implying any racial sentiments, so don’t get work up :)) the Malay household is slightly higher at 5 on average, while the Chinese is 2.5. Not sure about the rest.
Look at the data, 57.8% is earning RM3K and below, while if you take the next income bracket, which is RM3001-4000 into account, we are at 70.7% and that answer some of you that was talking about 2/3.
So I wonder from the stats above who is the one going to suffer the most and still listening to the racist warlords. Time for change!
I think Amirsham is showing his good capability. I would doubt that we can get this number if any other half cook ministers is involved.
But he did miss out one percentage of people earning millions a month and not having a proper job.
Hi Ijjaz
That’s why we need popular democracy and a mass movement to push for change.
It boils down to numbers (the forces of progress) versus money and abuse of state power (the forces of reaction).
In estates that is in oil palm estates and rubber estates the monthly wages is 250 to 350 how are they going to survive dont mention 1000 rm FORGOTTEN ABOUT THE ESTATES PLEASE CONSIDER I WILL APPRECIATE IF BROTHER ANILNETTO TO DO A SURVEY ON ESTATE WAGES AND PROBLEMS THANK U.
Singapore has much much much more FDI than Malaysia but its rakyat are an unhappy lot too, at times frownier than us, cos they lament that expats and other foreign talent over there has been snatching every opportunity from them…
The rich-poor divide is expanding by the year. It is a problem that seems persistent especially in Asia. As for us, i think a new tax slab would surely help, where in the groups within the low income bracket have a higher income limit.
International Tax Jobs