What? More Green Lane trees to be removed for road-widening

24
2483

In this era of climate change, I was alarmed to hear that up to three dozen big trees could be removed along Jalan Masjid Negeri (“Green” Lane) to make way for another car lane. (Update: Apparently, 16 trees could be involved or ‘transplanted’, not 33 as reported – but how many of these transplanted trees will survive?) This is the stretch across the road from the MacDonald’s outlet.

This road-widening project is expected to cost some RM15m. Is this the best use of our limited funds? Would it really solve our traffic problems? For how long?

In the past, certain people had to work hard to convince the JKR to save those trees. Back then, the Malayan Nature Society protested that Green Lane road-widening would cut down many trees, and it documented all this with photos. They apparently met the then Penang state ExCo member Khor Gark Kim about this and following that, he asked the JKR to change the alignment and spare the trees.

That’s why the double carriage-way road meanders along Green Lane, weaving its way past the trees, have you noticed?

And now we want to “relocate” or “transplant” the trees so easily? Apparently, some trees could be relocated a few metres away and others transplanted. But what is the survival rate of trees previously transplanted or relocated?

Penangites who care for our trees, please tell your elected reps that you DON’T want to see trees removed just like that, just to make way for more cars in our already congested island. Please make your feelings known.

READ MORE:  Alarming images of Botak Hill

The photos below show some of the trees before they were removed to make way for road-widening near the Green Lane-Udini roundabout. How many of those trees survived the uprooting and transplanting?

Please help to support this blog if you can.

Read the commenting guidlelines for this blog.

Join the conversation

24 Comments on "What? More Green Lane trees to be removed for road-widening"

avatar
2000
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
glissantia
Guest
glissantia

“A developed nation is not one where the poor drive cars. It is where the rich use public transport.” – Enrique Penalosa (ex-mayor of Bogota), 2011

tunglang
Guest
tunglang

Then Merc S300 Lansi will have to ‘chap-lap’.
Right or not, Mr Ah Piang?

Chew
Guest
Chew

Thanks for the write up. Quite a number of friends sharing this article and commented on it. Yes, there are still people that cares!

May i ask a practical question, what can we do over here?
whom should we write to stop this?
YB’s name? Department? or maybe an online petition?

Thanks!

Firedog
Guest

hahaha !No more green in Green Lane ?Call it Botak Lane lah !DAP govt like BOTAK !

Tang
Guest
Tang

YB Chow the traffic chief himself could be motor car lover hence seems not able to understand what is Green and what is Carbon?

benny
Guest
benny

The root cause of the problem is too many cars on the road.
Those who drive cars alone without passengers are the contributing to traffic congestion. People today love their cars more than the trees.
To save the trees, Penang must implement electronic road pricing to force people to use RapidPenang.

lim
Guest

Yes, benny, you are right, people today love their cars more than the trees !!! Everyone prefers their own cars, more convenient they say !!!

benny
Guest
benny

When they are stuck in the traffic jam, the last thing they would treasure are the trees.

Shebby
Guest
Shebby

Good point.

Patrick
Guest
Patrick

The problem is that, that stretch is not the bottle neck and not the root cause of the jam. Towards town, the jam happens at Jalan Utama turning to Macalister Road. Another bottle neck is the traffic light at turf club. Towards Penang bridge direction, the bottle neck is at the traffic light right after Mc. Donald and the stretch towards Penang bridge right after that.

zoro
Guest
zoro

Poor trees. But what about us? How many of us walk, bicycle or take public transport instead of using cars or kapchai? I use public transport because they are efficient but overcrowded during peak hours

Siew Eng Chuah
Guest
Siew Eng Chuah

Remember how trees were removed from the divider on jalan Tun Abdul razak to widen the road? That sure helped alleviate the traffic jam, right? Trees gone forever. Cars, hardly.

Ng Seksan
Guest
Ng Seksan

it is naive to think that these old trees will survive if relocated

Teresa Nelson
Guest
Teresa Nelson

Soon it will be know as Black Lane.

MO Kwan
Guest
MO Kwan
The authorities seem clueless about our traffic and liveability issues. They seem to prefer the LA model: Los Angeles is one huge freeway. Road widenings and adding new highways only solve local bottlenecks, they move the jam to some other road. The most pleasant cities in the world are not dictated by the motorcar. They are spaces for people, as opposed to the motor vehicle. By design, roads are made narrow to preserve the liveability of the city spaces. Trees are a most precious component in the urban streetscape, they connect man to Nature, give shade, reduce glare and ambient… Read more »
Lau
Guest
Lau
If tree need to be removed, just remove them, don’t waste resources by transplanting. It was a stupid idea to save tree trunks as their growth are slower than brand new plants, and it cost lots of money to do so. It is time to take serious survey of why people travel, and how they travel, and what alternative can be made available to the road user. By the way, don’t discount the new mode of travel by using personal transport device like road rover, a skate board like motorized unit that work well with mass transit system for difficult… Read more »
Kah Seng
Guest
Kah Seng

“Green” Lane will be connected directly to the Pulau Tikus area and will hence adopt the other road’s name – “Brown Road.”

Sukhindarpal Singh
Guest
Sukhindarpal Singh

The only green left soon shall be green coloured roads painted green

Gwynn Jenkins
Guest
Gwynn Jenkins

so the green penang was about the lovely bicycle lanes after all and nothing about trees!

YK Leong
Guest
YK Leong
The Angsana trees along the roads of the Penang General Hospital, Western Road, York Road, Scotland Road and Green lane were planted in 1884 or thereabout by the first curator of the Penang Botanic Gardens by Charles Curtis. However, in the 1920s, a fungal disease killed off many of the trees and there was a second mass planting of Angsana to replaced those that have died. This were planted by Flippance , then curator of the Penang Botanic Gardens. This account was given by Professor R.E. Holttum, a former director of both the Penang Botanic Gardens and Singapore Botanic Gardens.… Read more »
Michelle Quah
Guest
Michelle Quah

No!!!!!!!!! My my those trees are precious!

MalaysianFirrst
Guest
MalaysianFirrst
Been around he world. Seen too many things to open up my previously CLOSED mind. All other countries are narrowing down roads, to around 10 feet. Cutting down the numbers of cars on the street. They have walkways for all of their citizens, pedestrian and disabled alike. They have bicycle paths. They have “CAR FREE DAYS”. The higher or wider the road, most motorist will tend to SPEED up, usually ending up with disastrous ACCIDENTS. As a result, head injuries usually occurs WITHIN the car, more than 50%. Why the need for SAFETY BELT and AIR BAGS, if cars are… Read more »
Tang
Guest
Tang

Be careful some folks may associate expanded mind as being radicalized mind that like to challenge the status quo. Anyway, good write up only if the motor-crazed public can emphatize with.