Nizar and Perak Speaker Sivakumar anxiously await the results last night
What an incredible last few days it has been. And thank you to all the “citizen journalists”, political activists and even mainstream media folks who fed me information, including complete strangers such as the young man who passed me the video he took of the teargas incident in Air Kuning. Thanks for all your kind words and encouragement, which kept me motivated.
I left Perak this afternoon after lunch at a kopitiam restaurant in Taiping with much to think about (and I don’t mean just the cendol).
Bukit Gantang ushers in a new phase in Malaysian politics. Ethnic and religious barriers were broken here as the Chinese and others voted in droves for Pas. Much of it was due to the more moderate face of Pas projected by its popular candidate, Nizar, and the party’s makeover “Pas for all”. The close cooperation among Pakatan parties, and more importantly, the interaction of ordinary people on the ground also contributed to the breakthrough.
In staging its power grab in Perak, Umno may have committed its biggest blunder. By ousting Nizar, it allowed him to be chosen as a candidate for a parliamentary seat, thus propelling him to a bigger stage – Parliament, where he will now be a regular face in front of a national audience.
His overwhelming acceptance among minority groups is something that Umno leaders cannot match – unless they dump their divisive brand of racial politics.
Here’s an article I wrote in Perak this morning for Asia Times, just before returning to Penang:
Malaysia’s Najib fails his first test
By Anil Netto
BUKIT GANTANG, Perak – Malaysia’s ruling coalition lost two of three by-elections held on Tuesday, in a result that shows that the change in prime minister from Abdullah Badawi to Najib Razak only four days prior has done little to stem the erosion in popular support for government led by the United Malays National Organization (UMNO).
Many viewed the three local polls as an early referendum on the new premier, who took over after the UMNO-led ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition suffered a setback at general elections held in March last year. The BN lost five states to the People’s Alliance opposition, made up of the Pan-Malaysian Islamic party (PAS), the Democratic Action Party (DAP), and the People’s Justice Party (PKR), led by Anwar Ibrahim.
Full article here.
Thanks for the excellent coverage, Anil. I was soaking in the excitement & camaraderie at the Cherry Inn media center where the Barisan Rakyat Bloggers & Malaysiakini had taken rooms. Would have been lovely to meet you… another time!
Yes! Hopefully we get to meet another time. Anil
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
I agreed with your analysis. Nizar certainly have the characteristic of a PM to be and very much liked by all Malaysian regardless of their races.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
“UMNO’s assertion of its control over the state a month earlier.”
You got it. UMNO’s ASSERTION…
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
“BN’s component parties can only mobilize token Chinese and Indian voters.”
MCA, however, still thinks they deserve their cabinet seats. You can downsize all you want, so long as our numbers remain the same, seems to be their message.
Good ole Samy was the first to take a dig. We, at the MIC, don’t make such demands.
Maybe MCA should bring back its own good doctor and see what remedies he might have to offer.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Alhamdulilah Melayu Cina India bersatu hati menyokong MB Nizar dan YB Manikumar.
MB Nizar = prime minister material
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
if i choose to see things the way the blogger see things, i believe if 16 september ever happen, i will say ‘its democracy. everybody can choose whoever he/she likes’
then BN will be history and anwar, despite his non-commitment to PKR ( if the adviser to PKR is considered a post, then I’ll retract the sentence ) will be appointed PM. guan eng, karpal, hadi, etc etc they have to step aside for anwar to be named PM.
thats the logic if i choose think and see things like the blogger is seeing now.
but no. we cant do that.
lets recap what happen. Pakatan Rakyat got hold Perak with 3 majority. appointed Sivakumar as DUN’s Speaker. and Hee as the deputy. then the 3, two from pkr and one from DAP choose to be INDEPENDENT despite their winning DUNs on PR’s tickets. 2 of the 3 were heavily involved with immoral activities where they took the offer of Chinese prostitutes from someone.
Then Nasharuddin of BN announced he wanted to join PR which saw Anwar rejoicing him himself. Nik Aziz delivered a so-called ‘fatwa’ saying it is human choice and nothing wrong with party hopping. Karpal said nothing. his son too kept quite.
Few days later, U turn. and the 3 hoppers hopped into INDEPENDENT, with preference to support BN. I have to stress here that they DID NOT hop into BN! Then BN people went to see Sultan and Sultan himself asked to see all the 3 INDEPENDENT ADUNs plus all BN’s ADUN. Sultan satisfied.
Before that event happen, Nizar realised he being checkmated and tried to meet the Sultan to seek permission to dissolve ADUN. he tried too late.
I cant see where the hell was BN’s so called dirty tactic i.e threaten them to go INDEPENDENT or asked Sultan not to give permission to dissolve DUN. But many people choose to assume that, there were somethings done by BN.
But nevermind, Nizar already won Bukit Gantang and I wish him all the best. I dont think he will be re-instate as MB regardless of what circumstance coming ahead. I am all interested to see how Nizar will try to develop his Parlimentary area as well as his DUN area, true to his promises to the voters.
wish him all the best.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
In a rather comical way, we owe our thanks to UMNO. Without UMNO’s high handed tactic of ousting the lawful government of Perak, we may notget to see Malay, Chinese, Indian and Kaum Lain2 can stay united for the well being of the Nation.
Kutty, Najib and UMNO tried very hard to split us, but we stand our ground!! Now we can tell them to go eat …!!!
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Nil, we in Perth do appreciate your great effort, under trying circumstances to keep us informed and live! Glad you made it up with your cendol which I am willing to swap for my glass of vintage wine.
Yes, Nizar is the man of tomorrow. He reminded me of the good old days when Tuanku Abdul Rahman was PM…down to earth and mixes well with the rakyat. He is God sent to PR…hopefully, he will bring back the close integration of all races and bury the racial parties for good.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Thanks for the excellent coverage of the elections.
And any numbers as yet for total PRDM election-policing spend, particularly on those cheap as chips, vfm canopies?
“Imagine Power To The Power” John Lennon.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Terima Kasih Anil for your report.
Syabas Pakatan Rakyat !
Good to see Malays,Chinese,Indians in Nizar Constituency UNITED to bring about Change,Democracy,A Society FREE OF DISCRIMINATION,Free of Rampant Blatant Corruption
A government of Unity with Tengku Razaleigh as Advisor and
Anwar as Prime Minister with his Team of Nizar,Nik Aziz,Zaid Ibrahim ,Guan Eng,Gobalakrisnan,Uthaya,Wathy,Kit Siang,Husam Musa Raja Petra, will be a Dream Team.
Hidup Reformasi……REJECT Racism & discrimination
Hidup Ketuanan Rakyat !
Thank you Good people of all 3 Constituency for voting Pakatan Rakyat !
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
[...] here: Umno’s power grab propels Nizar to national stage a-folks-who, incredible-last, last-night, perak, perak-speaker, Politic, the-results, the-young, [...]
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Anil Netto!
You have always been somewhat rational in your writings & comments!
So I need to ask you & place on your lap this matter for consideration:
Does the word/expression MAGNANIMITY ever feature in the hearts/souls of the powers that be{ PTB } ?
Does the PTB ever SEE THE WRITING ON THE WALL ?
Would it not have been the right/proper/moral/ethical course of action for the PTB to accept GRACIOUSLY/HUMBLY the RAKYAAT’s decision of 080308, & get on with serving the RAKYAAT first & foremost?
Does the PTB have to keep shennaniganising{my creation}the RAKYAAT until the implosion occurs?
Cheers & Godspeed!
Mr.M
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
drMpower,
The 3 INDEPENDANTS can also vote in favour of the PR (instead of the BN) because though they are independant and “say” they will vote in favour of BN, who is to say that they will not be a turncoat to the BN ?
Remember, these 3 so-called independents had vowed to the Sultan of Perak in 2008 that they are with the PR coalition but now in 2009, they say that they are now “have preference” with BN. …
But now, you have a situation of 28 lawan 28 with 3 independants who could go either way. This does not provide stability to any party forming the Perak govt, be it the BN or PR.
The other fundamental issue is really that the 3 now-independant ADUNS were voted in on the back of the political party which they were formally nominated under. If they had been independants all along, there is no issue.
Really boils down to a matter of PRINCIPLE. Look at the ex-Assemblyman for Bt Selambau, Mr Arumugam. He was under duress from some parties and stepped down, hence leading to the by-election. Why couldn’t these 3 now-independants do the same? At least give due respect to your electorate to make their choice.
As for Nizar, the legal issue is whether he is still the MB. Was he sacked by the Sultan ? Did he resign ? If the answer is no to either question, then he is still the MB. Of course, Dr Zambry can also be appointed MB by the Sultan tapi dua kepala mesti pening lah.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Dear Anil
UMNO/BN nightmare coming true:
Chinese voting for PAS
Malays voting for DAP
Multiethnic PKR growing from strength to strength
YES, WE CAN! MALAYSIA BOLEH!
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
drMpower
You forgot quite a bit in your narration (DrM’s famous selective memory, huh?).
- Where, in the Perak constitution, is the sultan’s power to remove the MB?
- Where, in the Perak constitution, does it say “sorry MB you are asking for DUN dissolution too late”? If you can answer both questions, my advice: go to the ever-neutral AG and submit to him
- Why is the federal executive power (FRU, PDRM) mingling in state legislative affairs (preventing the DUN from meeting)? What business does the same federal power have preventing access to state offices to exco members who have not resigned!
- Why is the judiciary, JC Ridzwan who has consequently seen his contract renewed for 2 years, requiring the Perak speaker to be defended exclusively by the State Legal Officer? Knowing full well the Speaker is not a state agent! The same is not required from Zambry…
- If Zambry is legitimate, why does he not call up a DUN meeting? How long will the state government, legitimate or otherwise, run without DUN supervision?
- Do not even get me started on this new party: “BN-friendly independent BUT they are NOT BN”.
If you do not see massive power abuse at the hand of the federal government/ BN here, then I guess you are blind.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
So the Perak power grab by Umno is not such a bad thing after all. It turns out to be a blessing in disguise for Pakatan. Maybe Najib should now grab Kedah as well as Umno try to do. It’s a good way for Pakatan to get rid of all those greedy frogs presently hiding in the coalition. Kedah fall will hasten the delivery of the federal government to Pakatan in the next general election.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Anil,
You can now have a good rest after your great effort the last week to share the fruits of your hard labour.
With the incoming PM & his DPM (who needed Mahathir’s support at the AGM!) now inviting Mahathir membership #0000001 to be their “Adviser”….
They have all now “Succumbed” to “Mahathir’s Trap”
Together with his 2 sons he is now the “Taiko” to continue from where he left the last time….
Najib….
Bodoh….remove MB Mohd Nizar but forgot to remove Speaker Sivakumar!
….invite Mahathir to rejoin UMNO but forgot to help Mukriz to remove KJ at the AGM!
Now….even Mama cannot help you, Stupido!
There will definitely be “Fireworks”, so let us sit back & watch the show….
“Devine Intervention” works “Wonders”….
You go figure out….
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Yes, the way forward is to provide hope for the poor Malays who have been given wrong impression of ketuanan melayu. PRK or Pg Governement should start a school to train future malay leaders for a One Malaysia. This will prepare them for GE13…..the way forward, give good deserving malays leadership training and fight corruption!
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Thank you Anil for the live updates. I know you worked hard to cover the events at Bukit Gantang. The erratic weather, traffic jams and bad broadband service did not make your job easier! Thank you again!
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
God has a way of reeling back the excess of man. First he make mad the man he want destroyed. Read UMNO and BN. Then he sent a guide to lead the way out of the mess. Read Nizar.
This story is repeated age after age. Nothing is permanent. No privilege is god given.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Superb article that you wrote in Asia Times Anil. Thanks
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
The man of the hour
The triumph in Bukit Gantang
It sent a shivering signal
The number 6 didn’t want to hear
The bad nights
The haunting dreams
On Cheng Beng black knight took office
The day the ghosts walk free
The days ahead
The shadow feeling afraid
Of the unfinished businesses
Ringing up in his brain
The man of the hour
Nizar triumphed against all odds
Only the people of Perak
They decide the politician’s fate
The democracy under the tree
The black knight couldn’t smile any more
The light is glowing majestically
He knows he can’t escape
A short lived scene
The ghosts dancing in his dream
Nizar waving smiling at his easy pace
“Come to Perak
PR will bury you with votes”
The black knight stops
Eyes glaring fear in his soul
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
This man is destined to lead as such anil, nothing can be taken from a man of god.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
The finest achievement that Nizar made in his short tenure at the top was the transformation of the views that the non-malays had of Pas.
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
“melayu kembali kepada umno?”
because to fight a single race imperialism. islam does not teach this.
because of rm and a bicycle. islam does not teach this.
because of suratkhabar lama…………how low can you go?
Complain about this comment
Like or Dislike:
0 
0